Poppy’s Pizzeria

Mark Boucher a month ago

Calzone was really good. Buffalo Garlic Parm wings were on the dry side. They were good but not great. Seemed like most of the sauce soaked through the takeout container. PB&J wings are better called peanut butter wings. I could see jelly on them but couldn't taste it, ended up dipping in my own jam. Pizza wasn't my cup of tea but others in my family loved it. I think if you like a thicker crust you will like it

Ann H. 2 months ago

We were visiting the area and found online that this place has great reviews. We decided to try this place. The people are very nice and friendly. We ordered a large cheese pizza. The pizza came in super hot and fresh. We really wanted to like the pizza but it’s not that good. I even put a bunch of Parmesan cheese shaker on the pizza. Even the Parmesan cheese doesn’t have much flavor. Our 6 year old who loves cheese pizza only had one slice which he normally eats at least 2 slices of pizzas. We mostly ate the cheese on top. Maybe this place has great reviews coz of the ice cream next door. But the pizza was very disappointing.

Joseph Stacey Edited a month ago

Super friendly and helpful staff. Owner personally came to check on us and how we enjoyed the pizza. We got garlic knots (delicious). A large cheese with meatball toppings, and The Gabby (broccoli, oil, mozzarella, and ricotta). All pizzas were delicious ! Prices are very reasonable. Calzones are great too! Eat inside or outside.

Adam Fusco 7 months ago

TRY THE PB&J WINGS!!!! Ordered two pizzas and two orders of wings. Owner was super friendly and presented the pizzas to me like a proud father. Very relaxed atmosphere and spacious parking.

Steve Battiste a year ago

Disclaimer, the new owner and I are friends. I loved his food at his previous endeavor, his rolls are heavenly. I wanted to try out the new place but I live out of town. I came into the area to go to a party. I ordered some food from Poppy’s for the party . I brought baked ziti, buffalo wings and a tray of garlic knots. When I showed up at the party, I dropped the food but needed to move the car down the street. Saying hello to people as I made my way to the food table. People kept walking up and complementing the food I brought, I better get a plate! By the time I got to the table, I there were only 2 wings, a little baked ziti and some of the huge garlic knots left. I was glad to get it. Wings were terrific. The knots had some garlic butter. There was extra sauce provided for the pasta. We got some additional HOT sauce for the wings on the side which people poured on some of the other food that was there since it was so good. I wanted to take some pictures of the food, the only thing that I could do was take pictures of mostly empty containers. Let me say it again, short time between drop off and all food was gone. Big thumbs up!